Block 34 on East Park Avenue is where New Plymouth's First Baptist Church stood. In spring 2025 the property came before the city as Pilgrims Cove, a subdivision proposed by Sky Investments and Rywest Homes on six original townsite lots, numbered 5 through 10. It took two meetings to get a plat approved for a few houses on one block.
That project is a good model for how New Plymouth grows. New homes here come a few lots at a time, mostly inside the streets the town already has. Meanwhile, the Payette County market around it is selling resale homes faster than at any point in the past year. For a buyer comparing New Plymouth with Fruitland and Payette, that means the house you end up with in New Plymouth is most likely one somebody already lives in.
Two meetings for one church block
On April 28, 2025, New Plymouth's Planning and Zoning Commission sent Pilgrims Cove to the City Council with an unfavorable recommendation. Commissioners still had questions about a sewer easement setback and the drainage pond calculations. The P&Z minutes record a motion for a favorable recommendation that failed, followed by a motion against that passed.
A week later, on May 5, 2025, the council approved the final plat after the city engineer reported that the concerns had been reviewed, according to the council minutes from that night.
The size of the project is what a buyer should take from it. Pilgrims Cove adds homes on one block of the original townsite, and most of New Plymouth's recent additions are about that size.
Five lots behind East Boulevard
The second 2025 plat came from River Brook Custom Homes and was even smaller. It covered two original townsite lots on a 0.966-acre site behind 200 East Boulevard. At the April 7, 2025 hearing, the applicant's engineer described five lots for Good Lane East, and the council approved the preliminary plat. It adopted the findings of fact on May 5.
Residents spoke at the same April meeting about water resources, impact fees, fire safety and a possible growth moratorium. The April 7 minutes record those as comments. The council did not adopt a moratorium. A five-lot infill plat still drew that discussion, so you can see why New Plymouth's builders work in small batches. If you have walked the town's horseshoe streets, these sites sit in the same compact grid we wrote about when the city closed the gap in its horseshoe path.
Pilgrims Cove and Good Lane East are approved plats. When you tour, ask your agent where each site stands that week.
The one builder community: Rosemary and Pine
New Plymouth has one builder-scale project. CBH Homes is building The Hamptons around Rosemary Avenue and Pine Street, with homes at addresses including 610 Rosemary Avenue and 511 Pine Street. The builder said in December 2025 that construction had started.
CBH's community page, dated October 1, 2026, showed five available homes from 1,364 to 2,636 square feet, some still under construction. Asking prices ran from $359,995 to $489,995. That range puts the cheapest new build roughly $75,000 below Payette County's September median sale price and the largest about $55,000 above it.
That matters when you price an older house in town. A seller with a 1950s bungalow near the park and a buyer looking at The Hamptons can see the same new-construction prices a few blocks apart, and that tends to set the ceiling for in-town resale of a similar size. If you're weighing older homes against newer ones, we break down the town's housing stock in our guide to New Plymouth home styles and micro-neighborhoods.
A quiet year at the planning table
The one recent request to bring new land into town stopped short in late 2025. According to the city's hearing notice, the William Cummings Estate asked to annex a parcel across SW 2nd Avenue from 4167 SW 2nd Avenue. On October 27, 2025, the applicant told Planning and Zoning the goal was to make the land more marketable. The commission recommended against it, concerned that the parcel could stay undeveloped and that it had no master plan. The council's November 17, 2025 agenda listed the annexation hearing. The minutes from that meeting record the first public hearing as canceled at the requester's request.
At that same meeting, the council voted 4 to 0 to repeal the 2002 Comprehensive Plan. It adopted the 2045 Comprehensive Plan with the Planning and Zoning Commission's recommendations and an updated land use plan. Since then the planning calendar has been quiet on housing. The commission's posted 2026 minutes, January through July, deal with zoning code work and a conditional use permit. None of them includes a subdivision or an annexation. The council's October 20, 2026 agenda carried a zone change from residential to commercial for 317 and 325 Holly Avenue.
The 2026 records show no new subdivisions on the city's calendar. Through next spring, the homes for sale in town will be the ones already standing plus whatever CBH and the 2025 infill builders finish.
What Payette County's fall numbers show
The countywide data points the same way. Boise Regional REALTORS publishes a monthly Four Rivers sheet covering Payette, Washington, Malheur and Owyhee counties. Its September 2026 sheet, built on Intermountain MLS data as of October 8, 2026, counts every single-family sale, new and resale.
| September 2026, single-family | Payette County | Washington County |
|---|---|---|
| Homes sold in September | 38 | 12 |
| Active inventory at month end | 99, down 28.3% from September 2025 | 63, up 3.3% from September 2025 |
| Pending sales | 54, up 42.1% from September 2025 | 18, up 38.5% from September 2025 |
| Days on market | 43, down from 64 in September 2025 | 127 |
| Months of supply | 2.9 | 5.4 |
Look at the mix of sales. Payette County's 38 closings in September matched August's total. New construction fell from 10 closings in August to 3 in September, and resale rose from 28 to 35 to make up the difference. So in September, almost all of the county's sales came from homes that already existed. That is the same pattern New Plymouth's planning records show.
Prices moved with it. Payette County's median sale price reached $435,000 in September 2026, up 7.3% from August and 14.5% from September 2025, the biggest year-over-year gain of the four counties. The sheet calls 4 to 6 months of supply balanced. At 2.9 months in September, Payette County was below that range. Washington County, just north, was inside it at 5.4. Of Payette County's 54 pending sales, 37 were expected to close in October. That pipeline was already full heading into the holidays.
These are county figures, and they cover Fruitland and Payette as well as New Plymouth. If you're also looking in Fruitland, its US-95 corridor follows its own pattern, which we covered in Fruitland's split price trend. In New Plymouth, the county trend lines up with the city records. The town has few new lots coming, and the county's buyers are mostly closing on resale.
What a New Plymouth buyer is shopping this winter
A buyer who chooses New Plymouth this winter will mostly be competing for homes that are already built and occupied. The Hamptons is the main exception, and its October range of $359,995 to $489,995 is a reference point for nearby resale. Pilgrims Cove and Good Lane East will add only a few houses on the original grid. With no new plats in the 2026 records, nothing larger is coming soon.
Because of that, the details of an older house carry a lot of weight here. Things like lot size, how close it is to the park, and what the seller has updated set the price more than they would in a town with a new tract opening every season. A buyer who has toured Fruitland's and Payette's newer subdivisions should expect to compare houses one by one in New Plymouth.
A few questions buyers ask
Is New Plymouth building a large subdivision right now? The records show CBH Homes' The Hamptons around Rosemary Avenue and Pine Street, with construction underway since late 2025, plus two small infill plats approved in 2025. Planning and Zoning's 2026 minutes from January through July include no new subdivision.
How fast are homes selling around New Plymouth? Payette County homes averaged 43 days on market in September 2026, down from 64 days in September 2025.
If you own one of the older homes buyers will be comparing against The Hamptons this winter, or you're trying to judge a New Plymouth listing against the new builds on Rosemary and Pine, Two Rivers Real Estate Company can go through the comparison with you, house by house. Start with a home valuation or reach out and Work With Us.